Tragedy strikes again in the Amish community when Ebenezer Fuller is found behind his barn, murdered.
Ettie Smith is convinced she knows the identity of the killer until she learns surprising facts about Ebenezer’s past. The more Ettie learns about him, the more things don’t add up. Hidden secrets, false identities, and a surprise visitor, all add up to a busy winter for Ettie Smith and her sister, Elsa-May.