Welcome to Cape Falls, a town with old-fashioned values. When Anna Myer’s parents died in a car accident, David and Paul Steer took her in and cared for her. For years she nursed a crush for the two men, only to be rejected and pushed away. Crushed with the rejection and believing the Steer Brothers could never love her the way she wanted, Anna left Cape Falls. Three years passed since she left the men she loved. Anna returns with a new determination and she knows the secret that David and Paul tried to keep away from her. There is a rumor that the Steer men share one woman. Anna wants to be that woman. Can she prove to Paul and David she is the woman they need? Can her men overcome their fears? And after so long of being alone will she finally belong to the Steer brothers?